I started my blog on May 1, 2011. In the last fourteen years, I have blogged every Sunday and every May 1! I could theoretically have a fourteen-year-old child, but instead I have a fourteen-year-old blog. For each anniversary, I like to do some kind of reminiscent post.
I thought I would do something a little different this year. You likely know my obsession with seasonal foods, so I thought I would elaborate on some of my rules and thought processes. (I did something similar in 2012, though that wasn't for an anniversary post.) So here goes.
When it comes to sweet things (dessert, candy, etc.), I generally only eat things that are holiday themed. (I also allow myself desserts made from produce we grow ourselves, but I won't get into that here.) Each holiday has its designated season. In 2018, I began allowing myself a grace period for leftovers, which is a much better way to handle it. (I used to make myself sick on Easter because I couldn't eat the candy after the holiday.)
If it's regular food, I can have it any time of the year, but some foods are especially suitable for certain times. (I have toyed with the idea of only eating holiday-themed meats, but that is difficult.)
I divide seasonal foods into different categories.
Category 1. These are foods that are iconic to the holiday, such as jelly beans, pumpkin pie, candy canes, etc. A comprehensive list follows.
Category 2. These are foods with special seasonal flavors. Category 2A consists of foods flavored like items in category 1: candy cane milkshakes, red velvet cookies, etc. This is my favorite category, and it's the driving factor behind my annual Pumpkinundation Roundup. Category 2B consists of foods with a flavor made specially for the season, but the flavor itself is not seasonal. These are often associated with colors. A good example is McDonald's Shamrock Shake. The minty flavor itself is not connected to St. Patrick's Day, but because it's green, it comes out seasonally.
Category 3. These are foods with a special shape or color, but the flavor is the same as their regular counterparts. Sometimes category 3 foods can become category 1. (Sugar cookies are iconic for Christmas and Valentine's Day, but they are category 3 for other holidays. Chocolate bunnies and chocolate eggs are category 1, but chocolate turkeys and chocolate Santas are category 3.)
Category 4. These are candies where only the wrapper is seasonal. You know the iconic Hershey's Kisses commercial with the ringing Kisses in red, green, and silver wrappers? Those are category 4.
I try not to buy categories 3 and 4, but I will eat them if they are given to me.
Here is a listing of the nine holidays I formally celebrate and their seasons, along with the regular foods and sweet foods that I classify as category 1. Also, I am always considering if additional foods should be counted, so I'm including ones that I haven't formally admitted.
New Year's, December 26–January 1. I actually allow myself to eat anything this week (for several reasons), but there are some specific New Year foods. The South has more New Year food traditions.
Regular foods: black-eyed peas
Sweets: sparkling cider, sparkling grape juice
Considering: cornbread, ham, turkey, confetti cake
Valentine's Day, January 15–February 14.
Sweets: red velvet cake and cupcakes, conversation hearts, chocolate-covered strawberries, chocolate cherry, chocolate raspberry, chocolates, sugar cookies, cinnamon candy, rose
Considering: cheesecake, Black Forest cake, Valentine's cupcakes, strawberry milk
St. Patrick's Day, February 15–March 17. I can eat anything green. Green food coloring alone is fine, but I prefer it if there's a flavor to go with it: mint, pistachio, lime, apple, avocado, etc. I can also have candy that comes in gold wrappers (like Rolos). I also count Lucky Charms as category 2B.
Regular foods: corned beef and cabbage, Irish soda bread, Irish stew, colcannon
Considering: potatoes, Irish potato candy (meant to look like potatoes, not made from potatoes), chocolate coins, mint shakes (currently 2B)
Easter, March 18–Easter Sunday.
Regular foods: roast ham, Easter eggs (hard-boiled eggs), carrots
Sweets: chocolate bunnies, chocolate eggs (various kinds), marshmallow chicks (Peeps), carrot cake, hot cross buns, jelly beans
Considering: Jordan almonds, chocolate crosses, lamb, lamb cake
Fourth of July, Friday before Memorial Day–July 4. I have added a lot of Fourth of July foods in recent years, but most of them are not specific to just the holiday.
Regular foods: hamburgers, hot dogs, corn on the cob, watermelon
Sweets: ice cream, rocket pops, popping candy, lemonade, apple pie, s'mores, flag cake
Considering: strawberry shortcake, fried chicken, potato chips, potato salad, cotton candy
Pioneer Day, July 5–July 24. Since I'm the world's leading expert on Pioneer Day, I get to make this up! I'm still figuring it all out.
Regular foods: watermelon
Sweets: saltwater taffy made in Utah, ice cream made in Utah, lemonade
Considering: sunflower seeds and sunflower butter, pie (generally), Utah foods: Utah scones, Jello, pastrami burgers, fry sauce, honey, funeral potatoes, frogeye salad
Halloween, September 15–October 31.
Regular foods: chili, pumpkin (as a vegetable)
Sweets: pumpkin (pumpkin spice, pumpkin pie), caramel apples, candy corn, candy pumpkins, popcorn balls, apple cider, apple cider donuts, Halloween candy (I'm still figuring out the difference between Halloween candy and regular candy)
Considering: colcannon, gummy worms, apple (generally), donuts (broadly), dry-ice root beer (but I don't really drink soda)
Thanksgiving, November 1–Thanksgiving.
Regular foods: turkey, stuffing, rolls/biscuits, cornbread, squash, pumpkin (as a vegetable), cranberry sauce, corn, sweet potatoes, gravy, pomegranate, green bean casserole
Sweets: pumpkin (pumpkin pie, pumpkin spice), apple pie, pecan pie, mincemeat pie, sweet potato pie, cranberry orange, candy corn, spiced cider
Considering: candy pumpkins (currently category 3), mac and cheese, pickles, olives
Christmas, day after Thanksgiving–December 25.
Regular foods: turkey, ham, red apples, oranges, cranberry
Sweets: candy canes, mint lozenges, ribbon candy, gumdrops, gingerbread (men, houses), sugar cookies, eggnog, hot cocoa, wassail, spiced cider, yule log cake, fruitcake, pumpkin pie, pecan pie, chocolate orange, chocolate cherry, cranberry orange, peppermint, spearmint, wintergreen, cinnamon candy
Considering: toffee, stuffing, nuts, popcorn tins, pine nuts, milk and cookies, archaic foods: plum pudding, figgy pudding, sugarplums
And here is a very long list of some of my most memorable (not necessarily good, but memorable) foods over the years, including their category. You will see that sometimes it is difficult to pinpoint a category. Since this is a blog-anniversary post, all of these foods were either on this blog or over on The Impulsive Buy. The rise of smartphones makes this all possible; I wouldn't make the effort to take pictures of these things with a digital camera (much less a film camera!).
 |
Van Leeuwen champagne ice cream, 2023/24. I am firmly anti-alcohol, but this does not have alcohol. 2A. |
 |
Homemade New Year's Day soup, 2024/25. Made with black-eyed peas, ham, and greens. 1 or 2A. |
 | Hot & Spicy Cinnamon Oreo, 2018. 2A. |
 |
Baskin-Robbins Secret Admirer (rose) and Love Potion #31 (chocolate raspberry) ice cream, 2022. 2A or 2B. |
 |
RubySnap February cookies, 2023: sugar cookie (1), chocolate cherry, red velvet, rose (2A), grapefruit, beet (2B) |
 |
Nebo Queen "leprechaun" (Lucky Charms and mint) shake, 2018. 2B. |
 |
Homemade avocado milkshakes, 2021. 2B. |
 |
Lucky Slice corned beef and cabbage pizza, 2023. 2A. |
 |
Homemade Irish soda bread cookies, 2023. 2A. |
 |
Normal Ice Cream fairy circle composed cone, 2023. 2B. |
 |
Homemade avocado pie, 2025. 2B. |
 |
Homemade carrot cake, 2018. 1. |
 |
Peeps cereal, 2019. 2A. |
 |
Homemade carrot pie, 2019. 2A. |
 |
Brach's Taco Truck Jelly Beans, 2022. 1. |
 |
Homemade hot cross buns, 2023. 1. |
 |
Pie Party carrot cake pie, 2025. 2A. |
 |
Pie Party Easter quiche, 2025. 2A or 2B. |
 |
Homemade chocolate carrot cake, 2025. 1, 2A, or 2B. |
 |
Stewart's Fireworks ice cream, 2018. 1 and 2A. |
 |
Dairy Queen Star-Spangled Blizzard, 2018. 1 (for Starkiss ice pop) and 2A or 2B. |
 |
Homemade apple pie, 2021. 1. (This is one of my most cherished Fourth of July memories because of the random blob of crust that ended up looking like a turkey. And also my cousin found a spider in his ice cream.)
|
 |
Homemade flag cake, 2023. 1. |
 |
Homemade cilantro ice cream, 2024. 1. |
 |
Campfire S'mores Cup Noodles, 2024. 2A. |
 |
Utah Taste Off Utah foods kit, 2021: honey (1), Jello cupcake (2A?), fry sauce (1), Thirst beignet (1?), Pioneer Chips funeral potatoes flavor (2A?)
|
Sweet Rolled Tacos banana cream pie ice cream (for Pie and Beer Day), 2024. 2A? |
 |
Caramel Apple Sugar Babies, 2018. 2A. |
 |
Zombie Skittles, 2019. 2B. |
 |
Last Course cinnamon ants ice cream, 2019. 2B. |
 |
Brach's Tailgate Candy Corn, 2022. 1 or 2A or 2B. |
 |
Burger King Ghost Pepper Whopper, 2022. 2B. |
 |
Baskin-Robbins Spicy 'n' Spooky Ice Cream, 2022. 2B. |
 |
7-Select pumpkin pie potato chips, 2017. 2A. |
 |
Last Course cranberry turkey ice cream, 2018. 2A.
|
 |
Brach's turkey dinner candy corn, 2020. 1 or 2A.
|
 |
Pumpkin Spice Cup Noodles, 2021. 2A. |
 |
Apple Pie Toast Crunch, 2021. 2A. |
 |
Homemade mincemeat cookies, 2021. 2A. |
 |
Trader Joe's green bean casserole bites, 2021. 2A. |
 |
Cutler's turkey stuffing cranberry sandwich, 2021. 2A. |
 |
7-Eleven Thanksgiving turkey sub, 2021. 2A. |
 |
Baskin-Robbins Turkey Day Fixins ice cream (sweet potato, cranberry sauce, cornbread), 2023. 2A. |
 |
Trader Joe's Turkey Sausage Stuffing Fried Rice, 2023. 2A. |
 |
Sugar Cookie Pop-Tarts, 2016. 2A. |
 |
Brach's FruitCake Nougats, 2017. 2A. |
 |
Exceedingly thick hot cocoa, 2019. 1. |
 |
Figgy Pudding Spam, 2022. 2A. |
 |
Brach's Holiday Heat candy canes, 2022. 1. |